Chargers and AC Adapters are Evil

OK, time for a twenty-first century rant:

One of the unfortunate side-effects of being a gadget freak is that I have a tangled and cumbersome collection of AC adapters, battery charges and automotive adapters, and Murphy’s law often dictates that I am missing the one I need at a crucial moment. This is also one of the more user-hostile aspects of living with electronic devices. The fact there exists no standard form factor, no standard connector and no intelligence in the AC/DC converter itself (most of them draw current whether or not they are plugged into the device they are meant to power or charge) means owners of these devices are stuck managing (and lugging around) a bunch of extra crap to support their coterie of gadgets, while these power adapters we all leave plugged into the wall waste epic amounts of energy, burning power 24×7, regardless of whether or not they are plugged in to a device.

This is clearly something that is broken and needs fixing, at least from the end-user’s perspective. I’d love it if, for example, all devices adopted a mini-USB plug and could easily charge off a laptop or a simple wall adapter with a hub to charge multiple USB ports. Or if all devices could charge via contact-less magnetic induction and could share a single charging station simply by being placed within a few inches of the charge-hub. Imagine if every desk, hotel and automobile came standard with a charging solution that was guaranteed to work with all your devices. Sure would be nice to only have to carry one charger around, or to carry none at all since you could be sure anywhere you went, you’d be able to find power for your devices.

I recall several years ago when a couple startups were pitching a technology for a standardized “charge-pad,” which was basically a powered place-mat with a mesh of wires on it that would charge any devices that were placed upon the pad, assuming the device had embedded this technology into it and had the special exposed contacts necessary to make contact with the pad and negotiate for its specific power requirements. Since I haven’t seen any such devices come to the market, I can only assume these companies failed to get funded or that they failed to drive adoption of their technology, which is not surprising given the dynamics I will describe below.

A market-driven solution to this is probably just a big pipe dream, and one that is not likely to be driven by any of the existing players in the industry. It is a boil-the-ocean, chicken-and-egg type problem. Until 90%+ of all devices out there adopt a standard, the benefits won’t be seen by most users, and it would take years for the existing install base to turn over. At least one company has a product that capitalizes on the inefficiency and stupidity of the status quo, and this is iGo, which manufactures the iGo everywhere power adapter that allows a user to power and/or charge two devices at a time using AC outlets, car power and airplane power. One can choose among a bewildering array of adapter tips to fit most popular devices. I get the impression that this has been a successful product for iGo.

I bought one myself and sometimes use it while traveling, but even the iGo falls short since it does not offer an adapter tip for the Sidekick II. And they’ll always always be one step behind the state-of-the-art. iGo can’t possibly provide tips for every device out there and won’t offer a new adapter until there is enough of an install base to warrant adding a new tip to their product line. So my hopes that iGo would solve my problems were dashed when I realized I still needed to travel with my charger for my Sidekick. And the charger only charges two devices at a time. I carry around a laptop, a cell phone, a couple iPods, a bluetooth headset and a Sidekick. Charging just two devices at a time doesn’t cut it. Plus, by the time you have an iGo and all the tips to go along with it, it pretty much occupies the same amount of space that all the other charges and power supplies did.

But the real reason reason why a standardized solution is unlikely to be adopted: retailers and the device manufacturers themselves enjoy the fat margins they reap from selling these over-priced accessories, so they’ve got no incentive to standardize. I’ve lost many chargers and automotive adapters (or left them behind on a trip and been forced to buy another lest my phone’s battery runs dry). Once, I even had to pay Sony $90 for a new battery charger for my DV cam. No way that thing cost them more than $5 to produce, but they know I can’t get the charger anywhere else and that if I want to use my $1000 video camera, I’ll have to pay their ransom. The waste and inefficiency of this is only felt by the user, not by any of the other players in the value chain.

Maybe the only way this could ever be solved is via some regulatory mandate. But AC adapters aren’t exactly a sexy issue for an enterprising politician to get behind, though the energy efficiency angle might be a viable way to drive change here. Maybe I’m just not thinking creatively enough about how to fix this…

If anyone has any bright ideas, I’d love to hear them. If someone could convince me there is a viable business model and/or sufficiently disruptive technological approach to attack this problem, I’d love to hear about it. Or if there is any political or regulatory movement with a sensible approach, I’d love to hear about that too.

Technorati Tags:

  • Mark Wong-VanHaren

    First, Ryan, post more often. I like your rants.
    A possible, partial answer: Apple. They create a cool charging device which works with all their gizmos. You & the missus both have iPods? Travel with just one charge-pad (chargePod?) and share.
    Then, since cool Apple did it, others decide to make chargePod-friendly devices.
    I suppose it wouldn’t have to be Apple. Could be Nokia, Moto, or anyone big enough to pull others along.
    Do I actually believe this would work? Nah. But I’d like to see them try.

  • Sam

    As an Apple fanboy, I’ll second Mark’s suggestion and also push it a bit further to claim that Apple has already made a tiny move in this direction. The Airport Express is a great device to travel with, since it lets you take 802.11g everwhere in a tiny package. Plus, the USB port will charge your iPod. Even better, my Sony-Ericsson k750i phone has a USB to phone cable that will charge when plugged into the computer. It ALSO charges when plugged into the airport express. So, with an airport express (or just an Apple USB AC charger) I can charge my iPod and my mobile. That’s nowhere near a solution, but it might be a start.

  • I power most of my devices with the souls of unbaptized babies. A completely functional solution. Yet no one is talking about it.

  • josh

    I bought a replacement AC adapter for my laptop about a month ago from http://www.laptopsforless.com and it works great. Is there any reason to think that a replacement AC adpater would be any worse that the manufacturers?

  • Everyone, your charging issues are over….the Chargepod(TM) is coming soon…check it out at http://www.callpod.com. This device will charge 6 devices at the same time (headset, iPOD, cell phone, etc.). Will surpass and redefine anything in the market today.

  • I couldn’t agree more. I recently lamented the same topic and described one company that tried to address it here: http://maxbley.typepad.com/maxs_blog/2007/03/great_unmarketa.html.
    I do hope the more recent entrants, like Callpod, can overcome the industry’s resistance.

  • The chargepod is now going to be available to the public this month – our commerce site will go live this week and we will begin shipping from our fulfillment facility.
    My Grandma once told me that “self-praise is no recommendation.” Notwithstanding this, I must tell you that this product rocks.
    Onward and upward….

  • The chargepod is now going to be available to the public this month – our commerce site will go live this week and we will begin shipping from our fulfillment facility.
    My Grandma once told me that “self-praise is no recommendation.” Notwithstanding this, I must tell you that this product rocks.
    Onward and upward….

  • Good day! Thanks for your work, admin!
    😉

  • This is a cool site! Thanks and wish you better luck! Brilliant but simple idea.
    😉

  • Beautiful site!
    😉

  • Very doll!

  • Your site has very much liked me. I shall necessarily tell about him to the friends.